Works inside album

[paultaylor]

(05-03-2018 16:34)simoncn Wrote:  It is a problem if a user-visible field in the tagging program (Grouping in this case) maps to different tags in the server depending on the format of the file. The user can usually work around this using aliasTags but might not realise why different types of files aren't being treated in the same way.

ContentGroup is usually displayed as Grouping to the end user. In your tag mapping page you are using the Flac/Vorbis Comment name as the logical name, but in this case I would say the logical name is in fact Grouping.

This is more update to date tag mapping file https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1...sp=sharing showing the mapping used by Songkong/Jaikoz and MusicBrainz Picard. Because Jaikoz was originally very much a MusicBrainz tagger we have always tried hard to maintain compatability with Musicbrainz Picard. You'll see that Picard also uses GROUPING for Flac/Vorbis rather than CONTENTGROUP, and that is why SongKong/Jaikoz use it. I dont know the prevalence of GROUPING versus CONTENTGROUP out in the wild.

[Yazsan55]

(05-03-2018 16:55)paultaylor Wrote:  

(05-03-2018 16:34)simoncn Wrote:  It is a problem if a user-visible field in the tagging program (Grouping in this case) maps to different tags in the server depending on the format of the file. The user can usually work around this using aliasTags but might not realise why different types of files aren't being treated in the same way.

ContentGroup is usually displayed as Grouping to the end user. In your tag mapping page you are using the Flac/Vorbis Comment name as the logical name, but in this case I would say the logical name is in fact Grouping.

This is more update to date tag mapping file https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1...sp=sharing showing the mapping used by Songkong/Jaikoz and MusicBrainz Picard. Because Jaikoz was originally very much a MusicBrainz tagger we have always tried hard to maintain compatability with Musicbrainz Picard. You'll see that Picard also uses GROUPING for Flac/Vorbis rather than CONTENTGROUP, and that is why SongKong/Jaikoz use it. I dont know the prevalence of GROUPING versus CONTENTGROUP out in the wild.

Many thanks Simon and Paul for sorting this out.

As Simon suggested I added Grouping: Group, ContentGroup:Group to aliasTags property and restarted Minimserver.
It didn't solve the problem; same result.

I thought it is because the file type is DSF, but the same issues with Flac files.

For your information please find the attached Jaikoz screenshots with MinimServer Group.

[simoncn]

As you have the correct values in "MinimServer Group", you don't need Grouping: Group, ContentGroup:Group in aliasTags.

Have you reloaded the MinimServer library in the LUMIN app?

What version number and update number of MinimServer are you using?

[Yazsan55]

Yes I have reloaded Minimserver library in Lumin app many times.
No difference.

My MinimServer version is 0.8.4.5

Thank you.

[simoncn]

What is the update number for MinimServer 0.8.4.5? You can find this by selecting About from the minim icon or by opening the status web page.

[Yazsan55]

I have applied update 114 now.
It is now displaying Works properly.
Thank you very much for your help, Simon and Paul.

One more thing.
The work automatically picks up/adds composer full name in front of Work value, which makes it very long.
Also, I do not need to know (normally) the composer name inside Album.
Is there any way I can configure omitting composer name for Work?

[simoncn]

If you don't want the composer name inside an album, you should remove Group.displayFormat={$composer^^: $group} from tagFormat.

Glad to hear update 114 has fixed the problem.

[Yazsan55]

Perfect thank you.
When did you release 114?

[simoncn]

Update 114 was released on 14th December 2017. All the release dates are on the Release Notes page.

It is a good idea to have the .autoUpdate property set to true. This will automatically install any new updates each time MinimServer is started.

[Yazsan55]

Thanks Simon. I just did that. Happy MinimServer now.