ReplayGain

[Hayden]

Hi,
Just a suggestion, would it be possible to add ReplayGain to transcoded audio files? I know this feature appears on at least one of the (inferior) rival audio servers, but MinimServer is my preferred choice and ReplayGain would be a very welcome extra.
Kind regards,
Hayden

[simoncn]

(10-03-2014 16:15)Hayden Wrote:  Hi,
Just a suggestion, would it be possible to add ReplayGain to transcoded audio files? I know this feature appears on at least one of the (inferior) rival audio servers, but MinimServer is my preferred choice and ReplayGain would be a very welcome extra.
Kind regards,
Hayden

Thanks for the suggestion. At the moment, I don't have any plans to add support for this.

[Hayden]

Hi Simon,
Thanks for considering it anyway and thanks again for the excellent MinimServer.

Kind regards,
Hayden

[Sloop John B]

Another vote for replay gain if it counts for anything. I find playlists are unworkable without it.

thanks

SJB

[simoncn]

(10-08-2014 20:59)Sloop John B Wrote:  Another vote for replay gain if it counts for anything. I find playlists are unworkable without it.

thanks

SJB

I'd like to clarify exactly what you are voting for. Do you want MinimServer to perform ReplayGain processing as part of transcoding or do you want MinimServer to copy ReplayGain tags from the source file to the transcoded stream?

[Sloop John B]

(10-08-2014 21:10)simoncn Wrote:  

(10-08-2014 20:59)Sloop John B Wrote:  Another vote for replay gain if it counts for anything. I find playlists are unworkable without it.

thanks

SJB

I'd like to clarify exactly what you are voting for. Do you want MinimServer to perform ReplayGain processing as part of transcoding or do you want MinimServer to copy ReplayGain tags from the source file to the transcoded stream?

I think I want the former. I want to have volume equalised via my replay gain tags so that when a track from a 1980s CD is followed by one from 2014 that I don't have to jump up and turn down the volume.

I use a Naim streamer which does not process the replay gain tags.

I appreciate the reply.

regards
John.

SJB

[simoncn]

(11-08-2014 11:18)Sloop John B Wrote:  I think I want the former. I want to have volume equalised via my replay gain tags so that when a track from a 1980s CD is followed by one from 2014 that I don't have to jump up and turn down the volume.

I use a Naim streamer which does not process the replay gain tags.

I appreciate the reply.

regards
John.

SJB

In that case, the answer is the same as previously given. At the moment, I don't have any plans to add support for this.

[Sloop John B]

(11-08-2014 12:45)simoncn Wrote:  

(11-08-2014 11:18)Sloop John B Wrote:  I think I want the former. I want to have volume equalised via my replay gain tags so that when a track from a 1980s CD is followed by one from 2014 that I don't have to jump up and turn down the volume.

I use a Naim streamer which does not process the replay gain tags.

I appreciate the reply.

regards
John.

SJB

In that case, the answer is the same as previously given. At the moment, I don't have any plans to add support for this.

That's a pity but once again thanks for the prompt replies.


SJB

[krutsch]

(11-08-2014 20:56)Sloop John B Wrote:  

(11-08-2014 12:45)simoncn Wrote:  

(11-08-2014 11:18)Sloop John B Wrote:  I think I want the former. I want to have volume equalised via my replay gain tags so that when a track from a 1980s CD is followed by one from 2014 that I don't have to jump up and turn down the volume.

In that case, the answer is the same as previously given. At the moment, I don't have any plans to add support for this.

That's a pity but once again thanks for the prompt replies.

SJB

+1 ... I would like to add my vote, as well (for processing during transcoding). Playlists really are difficult without it.

[Pepsican]

(28-08-2014 14:55)krutsch Wrote:  

(11-08-2014 20:56)Sloop John B Wrote:  

(11-08-2014 12:45)simoncn Wrote:  

(11-08-2014 11:18)Sloop John B Wrote:  I think I want the former. I want to have volume equalised via my replay gain tags so that when a track from a 1980s CD is followed by one from 2014 that I don't have to jump up and turn down the volume.

In that case, the answer is the same as previously given. At the moment, I don't have any plans to add support for this.

That's a pity but once again thanks for the prompt replies.

SJB

+1 ... I would like to add my vote, as well (for processing during transcoding). Playlists really are difficult without it.

+1 for me as well.

What would make you change your mind/priorities?