Post Reply 
"All Artists" index not honouring all.ignore.sort?
17-11-2026, 00:45
Post: #1
"All Artists" index not honouring all.ignore.sort?
Hi,

I have some Beatles albums which are tagged as:

ALBUMARTIST="The Beatles"
ARTIST="The Beatles"

In minimserver's configuration (Update 275), I have:

all.ignore.sort={The, THE, the, Sir, sir, SIR}

When browsing the "All Artists" (Artist tag values only), "The Beatles" appears under 'T' (I have alphaGroups configured for "All Artists" and "Album Artists"). However, in the "Album Artists" index, "The Beatles" appears under 'B', as expected with the all.ignore.sort configuration above.

Is there a reason why "All Artists" does not appear to honour the all.ignore.sort configuration?
Find all posts by this user
Quote this message in a reply
17-11-2026, 13:11
Post: #2
RE: "All Artists" index not honouring all.ignore.sort?
I am not seeing this problem. Please post your full configuration profile. You can find this by selecting Profies > View from the MinimServer configuration web page.
Find all posts by this user
Quote this message in a reply
17-11-2026, 14:18
Post: #3
RE: "All Artists" index not honouring all.ignore.sort?
Profile is:

Code:
aliasTags = artists:-artist, originaldate:-date, releasedate:-date, album artist:albumartist
alphaGroup = [albums]=50, [items]=50, All Artists, AlbumArtist, Artist, Composer, Conductor
contentDir = {/mnt/music/matt-delta}{/mnt/music/library}
indexTags = AlbumArtist:Album Artists, Artist:Main Artists, Date, Genre, All Artists, Composer, Conductor, Orchestra, Compilation=1:Compilations, *RecentAdded, *RecentPlayed, #AudioQuality
itemTags = AlbumArtistSort, ArtistSort, AlbumSort, ComposerSort, ConductorSort, OrchestraSort
serverOptions = indexArtwork=all
tagFormat = Artist.displayFormat={$artist$conductor$orchestra^^^ / }
tagOptions = Album.sortTags={AlbumArtist, Album}, all.ignore.sort={The, THE, the, Sir, sir, SIR}, Date.yearOnly.index
tagUpdate = /mnt/music/tag_update.txt
tagValue = Artist.value.sort={ArtistSort}, AlbumArtist.value.sort={AlbumArtistSort}, Composer.value.sort={ComposerSort}, Conductor.value.sort={ConductorSort}, Orchestra.value.sort={OrchestraSort}
writeTagChanges = tag_changes.txt
.profileVersion = 2.2

tagUpdate is just:

Code:
@ALBUMARTIST=Various Artists
+COMPILATION=1
Find all posts by this user
Quote this message in a reply
17-11-2026, 15:58
Post: #4
RE: "All Artists" index not honouring all.ignore.sort?
Thanks for this. Do the files showing this incorrect sort order have ArtistSort tags?

Also, are your files tagged with Artist tags or Artists tags? I am asking because I see artists:-artist in your aliasTags setting.
Find all posts by this user
Quote this message in a reply
17-11-2026, 22:21
Post: #5
RE: "All Artists" index not honouring all.ignore.sort?
(17-11-2026 15:58)simoncn Wrote:  Thanks for this. Do the files showing this incorrect sort order have ArtistSort tags?

Also, are your files tagged with Artist tags or Artists tags? I am asking because I see artists:-artist in your aliasTags setting.

All the files have an ArtistSort tag of "Beatles, The". I removed the ArtistSort from all the files in one Album, and it didn't make a difference; the Album still appeared under 'T'.

The "artists:-artist" entry is really there in case 'Artists' is encountered, but all the files in question have Artist (not Artists) tags.
Find all posts by this user
Quote this message in a reply
Yesterday, 18:50
Post: #6
RE: "All Artists" index not honouring all.ignore.sort?
What is odd, is that some artists are shown in the expected place in the "All Artists" index. For example, "The Corrs" appears under C and it has the same tag formatting (including ARTISTSORT tags) as "The Beatles" tracks. I thought that it might be where the ALBUMARTIST is not the same as (or is empty) as the ARTIST tag value, but this was a red herring (and I couldn't see the relevance).
Find all posts by this user
Quote this message in a reply
Yesterday, 21:50
Post: #7
RE: "All Artists" index not honouring all.ignore.sort?
If it works with The Corrs, there must be some difference in tagging that is causing it not to work with The Beatles. Are there any other artists appearing in the wrong place?
Find all posts by this user
Quote this message in a reply
Today, 11:10
Post: #8
RE: "All Artists" index not honouring all.ignore.sort?
Please check the MinimServer log for warning messages. If there is a conflict with the sort value (two ArtistSort tags for the same artist with different values), the sort value is ignored for that artist. If this happens, a warning message is written to the MinimServer log.
Find all posts by this user
Quote this message in a reply
Today, 16:09
Post: #9
RE: "All Artists" index not honouring all.ignore.sort?
Another thought: you have both

tagValue: Artist.value.sort={ArtistSort}

and

tagOptions: all.ignore.sort={The, THE, the, Sir, sir, SIR}

If both these ways of setting the sort value for an artist are used, the MinimServer user guide seems to imply that the tagValue setting takes priority. Does this explain what you are seeing?
Find all posts by this user
Quote this message in a reply
Today, 18:37
Post: #10
RE: "All Artists" index not honouring all.ignore.sort?
(Today 16:09)simoncn Wrote:  Another thought: you have both

tagValue: Artist.value.sort={ArtistSort}

and

tagOptions: all.ignore.sort={The, THE, the, Sir, sir, SIR}

If both these ways of setting the sort value for an artist are used, the MinimServer user guide seems to imply that the tagValue setting takes priority. Does this explain what you are seeing?

Thanks for the pointers. I found an erroneous ARTISTSORT on an MP3 file, which meant there were two different ARTISTSORT tags for a single ARTIST. I've removed this, and "The Beatles" is now in its expected location in the "All Artists" index.

In terms of the order of operations, I'd have expected that if there's a ARTISTSORT it would preferentially use that, but if the tag wasn't there it would fall back to using all.ignore.sort?

So, perhaps here because of the conflict, all.ignore.sort wasn't actually used (should it?), hence the placement of the Artist under 'T' in the 'All Artists' index? It appeared in the correct place in the "Album Artists" index because there wasn't a conflict in the ALBUMARTISTSORT tag?
Find all posts by this user
Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 


Forum Jump:


User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)